Preseason All-State
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Joseph Barberio | NY | Saint Mary's | 2017 | C | Canisius |
| Alex Bardo | NY | Corning Painted Post | 2018 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Bryce Berie | NY | South Jefferson | 2017 | 2B | |
| DJ Berry | NY | Brighton | 2017 | OF | Southern |
| Ethan Blaisdell | NY | Auburn | 2017 | 1B | Cayuga Community College |
| Aidan Booker | NY | Shaker | 2017 | 2B | |
| Noah Bowen | NY | Westmoreland | 2017 | C | Jefferson Community College |
| Evan Bowers | NY | SUNY Adirondack | 2018 | OF | SUNY-Adirondack CC |
| RJ Brandon | NY | Canisius | 2018 | 2B | |
| Tony Burlingame | NY | Horseheads | 2018 | OF | Fredonia State University |
| John Cady | NY | Shenendehowa | 2017 | LHP | Albany |
| Will Carlone | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2019 | OF | Virginia Commonwealth |
| Andrew Carroll | PA | Honesdale | 2019 | RHP | Lackawanna JC |
| Matthew Ciezki | NY | St. Mary's High School | 2018 | 2B | |
| Jack Collins | NY | Canisius | 2018 | RHP | Binghamton |
| Gavin Collura | NY | St Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2017 | RHP | |
| Tanner Cooper | NY | Canandaigua Academy | 2017 | RHP | Penn State |
| Christopher Cramer | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2017 | RHP | Brockport State |
| Dylan Creasey | NY | Kenmore-East | 2017 | RHP | |
| Tyler Cyrus | NY | McQuaid Jesuit | 2017 | 1B | |
| Owen Dando | NY | Vestal | 2018 | SS | |
| Johnny Decker | NY | Albany Academy | 2018 | SS | Stony Brook |
| Matt Dessena | NY | Hornell | 2017 | RHP | St. John Fisher College |
| Jake Dippold | NY | Solvay | 2017 | LHP | Wofford |
| Ryan Enos | NY | Oriskany | 2017 | SS | SUNY-Oswego |
| Philip Ferranti, III | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2017 | C | Monroe Community College |
| Dalton Fischer | NY | John F Kennedy | 2017 | OF | |
| Antonio Fisher | NY | Hudson | 2017 | C | Keuka College |
| Dylan Frawley | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2017 | C | |
| Johnny Genau | NY | Williamsville South | 2017 | 2B | |
| Zac Granger | NY | Horseheads | 2017 | OF | University of Akron |
| TJ Gregory | NY | Chester Academy | 2018 | SS | St. Thomas Aquinas College |
| Tyler Griggs | NY | McQuaid Jesuit | 2019 | 3B | Connecticut |
| Robert Gruber | NY | Frontier | 2017 | LHP | Niagara County CC |
| Reilly Hall | NY | Cooperstown | 2017 | SS | Coker College |
| Jonah Harder | NY | Liverpool | 2017 | OF | Wilkes University |
| Troy Hattala | NY | Orchard Park | 2017 | C | |
| Parker Hendershot | NY | Tioga Central | 2017 | 3B | Penn State |
| Matthew Herasme | NJ | Don Bosco | 2018 | OF | |
| Jake Hernandez | NY | Guilderland | 2018 | 3B | St. John Fisher College |
| Johnny Hipsman | NY | Chester Academy | 2018 | OF | Richmond |
| Noah Hockaday | NY | Bath-Haverling | 2018 | RHP | |
| Tyrell Irvis | NY | Ravena-Coeymans-Selkirk | 2019 | RHP | College of Saint Rose |
| Bryce Jellinick | NY | Grand Island | 2017 | LHP | |
| Erik Johnson | NY | McQuaid Jesuit | 2018 | LHP | Niagara County CC |
| Jake Johnson | NY | Orchard Park | 2018 | SS | |
| Brent Jones | NY | Proctor | 2017 | 2B | Canisius |
| David Judge | FL | Calvary Christian | 2019 | OF | Florida International |
| Ryan Kalbfus | NY | Penfield | 2017 | 1B | Gannon University |
| Brandon Kelley | NY | Horseheads | 2018 | RHP | |
| Matt Kellner | NY | Frontier Central | 2017 | 3B | Fredonia State University |
| Kevin Kelly | NY | Averill Park | 2017 | SS | |
| Joseph Kosowsky | NY | Lansingburgh | 2018 | 3B | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Matt Kot | NY | West Genesee | 2018 | 3B | |
| Gavin Krawiec | NY | St. Francis | 2019 | RHP | Niagara |
| Kyle LaPlante | NY | Kenmore West | 2017 | SS | Niagara |
| William Lawrence | NY | Canisius | 2017 | C | Niagara County CC |
| Nico Limoncelli | NY | Horseheads | 2017 | SS | Polk State College |
| Michael LiVorio | NY | Bay Shore | 2017 | OF | |
| Jared Lonergan | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2018 | LHP | |
| JT Lopez | NY | Shaker | 2018 | RHP | |
| Steven Malara | NY | Frankfort-Schuyler | 2017 | 1B | |
| Logan Martella-Tasick | NY | Penfield | 2017 | OF | Monroe Community College |
| Michael Mazzara | NY | Canisius | 2017 | C | Canisius |
| Brendan McGillin | NY | Amsterdam | 2017 | 2B | |
| Sean McKinney | NY | Lockport | 2019 | C | Keuka College |
| Devan Mederios | NY | Liverpool | 2017 | OF | |
| Austin Meenaghan | NY | Starpoint | 2017 | 1B | |
| Evan Menendez | NJ | Christian Brothers Academy | 2017 | LHP | |
| Sam Messana | NY | Niagara Wheatfield | 2018 | 3B | Erie CC |
| Jack Migliore | NY | Hamburg | 2019 | OF | Canisius |
| Domenic Monti | NY | Lancaster | 2017 | 2B | |
| Demitri Murray | NY | Lansingburgh | 2017 | LHP | Iona |
| Justin Mytych | NY | Penfield | 2019 | RHP | |
| Brayden O'Connell | NY | Horseheads | 2018 | OF | |
| Daniel Owen | NY | New Hartford | 2018 | RHP | College of Saint Rose |
| George Pappas | NY | Susquehanna Valley | 2017 | C | New Haven |
| Peyton Parmeter | NY | Avon | 2018 | RHP | Corning CC |
| Jordan Peltier | NY | Shaker | 2018 | OF | |
| Zach Penksa | NY | St. Marys | 2017 | SS | |
| Andrew Perry | NY | Shenendehowa | 2018 | 3B | SUNY-Cortland |
| Jake Podlas | NY | Canisius | 2018 | RHP | |
| Sean Pufpaff | NY | Grand Island | 2017 | 3B | |
| Daniel Purcell | NY | West Genesee | 2018 | C | |
| Renato Quinones | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2017 | OF | |
| Ethan Radley | NY | Rensselaer | 2017 | RHP | Keuka College |
| Brendan Reilly | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2017 | 2B | Brockport State |
| Jacob Riester | NY | St. Joseph's Collegiate Institute | 2018 | OF | |
| Mitchell Rosati | NY | Canisius | 2017 | OF | |
| Steven Rossi | NY | Corning | 2018 | RHP | Suffolk University |
| Joshua Rudock | NY | Susquehanna Valley | 2019 | OF | |
| Anthony Russo | NY | Arlington | 2018 | RHP | |
| Zach Scannell | NY | Liverpool | 2017 | 1B | Robert Morris University |
| Sam Schatmeyer | NY | Williamsville East | 2017 | RHP | |
| Tommy Scherrer | NY | Skaneateles | 2018 | RHP | Union College (NY) |
| Jacob Schettine | NY | Marcellus | 2017 | LHP | Brockport State |
| Dominick Spinoso | NY | Christian Brothers Academy-Syracuse | 2017 | RHP | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Kyle Spoth | NY | Williamsville North | 2017 | 3B | |
| Lucas Stalman | NY | King Low Haywood Thomas (CT) | 2018 | C | |
| Connor Stanton | NY | Cicero-North Syracuse | 2017 | OF | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Michael Steffan | NY | Williamsville East | 2017 | SS | Canisius |
| Josh Surowiec | NY | Williamsville North | 2017 | 1B | Mercyhurst University |
| Ty Syta | NY | St. Francis | 2018 | C | Le Moyne College |
| Christian Szablewski | NY | St. Marys | 2018 | OF | St. Bonaventure |
| Mitch Taylor | NY | Tioga | 2018 | RHP | |
| Alec Teska | NY | Cato-Meridian | 2017 | RHP | St. John Fisher College |
| Andrew Thompson | NY | Horseheads | 2018 | C | |
| Julian Thompson | NY | Shaker | 2019 | SS | Iona |
| Zach Tojek | NY | Amherst | 2017 | 2B | |
| Collin Tytka | NY | St Marys | 2017 | RHP | |
| Brandon Underhill | ON | St. Michael Catholic | 2017 | SS | Niagara County CC |
| Jared Valvo | NY | St Francis | 2017 | C | |
| Joseph Von Holten | NY | Shaker | 2017 | C | |
| Matthew Von Holten | NY | Shaker | 2019 | RHP | |
| Alexander Wanat | NY | Williamsville North | 2017 | RHP | Brockport State |
| Sam Wheeler | PA | Sayre Area | 2018 | 2B | Hood College |
| Jarrod Williams | NY | Baldwinsville | 2017 | 3B | Finger Lakes CC |
| Adam Zebrowski | NY | Christian Brothers Academy | 2018 | C | St. John Fisher College |
| Jake Zurat | NY | Williamsville North | 2017 | C | Canisius |