Preseason All-State - Long Island
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Mike Badala | NY | West Islip | 2018 | C | |
| Nicholas Bettenhauser | NY | Shoreham-Wading River | 2019 | 3B | |
| Kevin Bowrosen | NY | Miller Place | 2020 | 3B | James Madison |
| Blake Burgan | NY | Sachem North | 2017 | SS | |
| Nicholas Burke | NY | North Babylon | 2019 | RHP | |
| Nicholas Carita | NY | Island Trees | 2018 | RHP | |
| Steven Carullo | NY | Commack | 2018 | C | |
| Joseph Chillino | NY | Clarkstown North | 2017 | C | |
| Evan Christopher | NY | North Babylon | 2019 | SS | Queens College |
| Andrew Ciufo | MA | Phillips Academy | 2019 | SS | Georgetown |
| Jonathan Cohen | NY | MacArthur | 2019 | OF | |
| Frankie Collora | NY | Ward Melville | 2020 | RHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Joe Comunale | NY | Sachem East | 2020 | SS | |
| Nick Comunale | NY | Sachem East | 2018 | RHP | Misericordia University |
| Wesley Cuevas | NY | New Dorp | 2018 | 1B | |
| Anthony DeNobrega | NY | Rocky Point | 2018 | 3B | |
| Anthony Dilluvio | NY | W.T. Clarke | 2019 | OF | |
| Andrew Ditzel | NY | Wantagh | 2018 | RHP | |
| Ryan Donofrio | NY | Massapequa | 2019 | 2B | |
| Gregory Dorfman | NY | Midwood | 2019 | RHP | |
| Kevin Edmonds | NY | West Babylon | 2018 | C | |
| Charlie Eisele | NY | Levittown Island Trees | 2019 | C | SUNY-Old Westbury |
| EJ Exposito | NY | St. John the Baptist | 2019 | SS | New York Tech |
| Nick Falcon | NY | Comsewogue | 2018 | OF | |
| Justin Fren | NY | Patchogue-Medford | 2018 | OF | |
| Chandler Giovinco | NY | Newfield | 2019 | RHP | |
| Samuel Goldfried | NY | Half Hollow Hills East | 2019 | OF | |
| Ryan Hancock | NY | West Babylon | 2018 | SS | |
| Ryan Kealy | NY | Plainedge | 2018 | OF | |
| Mason Kelly | NY | Shoreham Wading River | 2019 | OF | Furman |
| Liam Kennedy | NY | West Islip | 2018 | 1B | |
| Jesse Keshner | NY | Shoreham Wading River | 2018 | 3B | SUNY-New Paltz |
| Matthew Kohn | NY | George W. Hewlett | 2018 | LHP | |
| Zachary Kolano | NY | North Babylon | 2018 | 2B | |
| Matthew Laurelli | NY | Smithtown East | 2018 | 2B | |
| Donald Lent | NY | Deer Park High School NY | 2021 | LHP | Grayson JC |
| Jake Lynott | NY | Sachem North | 2018 | OF | |
| Ryan Mahon | NY | Mattituck | 2019 | C | |
| Justin Maler | NY | Bellport | 2019 | C | SUNY-Oneonta |
| Ryan Martin | NY | St. Francis Prep | 2019 | RHP | Iona |
| Christopher McLaughlin | NY | Half Hallow Hills East | 2019 | RHP | |
| Robert Milopsky | NY | Rocky Point | 2019 | 3B | Hillsborough CC |
| Peter Minneci | NY | Shoreham-Wading River | 2019 | 1B | Limestone College |
| Miguel Montesdeoca | NY | Massapequa | 2019 | C | |
| Vincent Morales | NY | Massapequa | 2018 | SS | |
| Christopher Morro | NY | Baldwin | 2018 | 2B | |
| Ryan Mullahey | NY | Shoreham-Wading River | 2018 | C | Long Island |
| Kyle Olson | NY | Sachem North | 2018 | OF | |
| Matthew Panker | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | SS | Colby College |
| Matt Pelcher | NY | IMG Academy | 2020 | C | Hofstra |
| Jordan Piht | NY | West Islip | 2018 | 3B | |
| Gregory Pimentel | NY | North Babylon | 2018 | SS | |
| Anthony Puidokas | NY | Plainedge | 2018 | C | |
| George Rainer | NY | Mt. Sinai | 2018 | SS | |
| Steven Rizzo | NY | St. Anthonys | 2019 | OF | Franklin & Marshall College |
| Jose Santana | NY | North Babylon | 2017 | C | |
| Stephen Santarpia | NY | New Rochelle | 2019 | SS | Merrimack College |
| Aidan Santiago | NY | Division | 2020 | LHP | |
| Joseph Sommer | NY | Kings Park | 2017 | RHP | |
| Justin Sonzone | NY | Massapequa | 2020 | SS | |
| Dylan Stalzer | NY | Sachem East | 2018 | 3B | |
| Paul Tammaro | NY | Clarkstown South | 2018 | SS | |
| Alex Ungar | NY | Connetquot | 2020 | 3B | Albany |
| Nicholas Ungar | NY | Connetquot | 2018 | C | SUNY-Oswego |
| Mark Vaughan | NY | White Plains | 2018 | OF | |
| Tristan Werner | NY | Mount Sinai | 2020 | 2B | Fairleigh Dickinson |
| Tyler Widercrantz | NY | Shoreham-Wading River | 2019 | OF | Saint Anselm College |