| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| John Michael Arminio | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | 1B | |
| Alec Bastone | NY | Fordham Prep | 2021 | RHP | |
| Jake Bernardi | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | 1B | |
| Edwin Betances | NY | Iona Prep | 2024 | SS | Lehigh |
| Jonthomas Bierman | NY | Mamaroneck | 2020 | SS | |
| Patrick Bowe | NY | Fordham Prep | 2022 | C | |
| George Calderon Jr. | MD | West Nottingham Academy | 2020 | 2B | |
| Jack Callahan | NY | New Rochelle | 2021 | RHP | |
| Joseph Capano | NY | Fordham Prep | 2022 | RHP | Trinity College (CT) |
| Jorge Caraballo | NY | Stepinac | 2021 | OF | |
| Patrick Carroll | NY | Iona Prep | 2023 | 2B | |
| Antonio Castillo | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2021 | RHP | |
| Tommy Chesnut | NY | Scarsdale | 2023 | RHP | |
| Frankie Cipriano | NY | Pelham | 2022 | 3B | |
| Paul Constantino | NY | Eastchester | 2021 | 3B | |
| Anthony Coppola | NY | Harrison | 2020 | OF | |
| Peter Coquillette | NY | Bronxville | 2022 | RHP | |
| Vincent Corso | NY | Harrison | 2020 | RHP | Richmond |
| Andrew Costa | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2022 | OF | |
| Cameron Cruz | NY | Salesian | 2021 | OF | |
| Dominic D'Onofrio | NY | The Harvey School | 2022 | LHP | Colby-Sawyer College |
| Anthony DeFabbia | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | OF | Stetson |
| Peter DeFabbia | NY | Lehman | 2022 | SS | Westchester CC |
| Alexander Del Brocco | NY | Eastchester | 2021 | OF | |
| Andre Delango | NY | Stepinac | 2023 | 2B | |
| Spencer Dessart | CT | Suffield Academy | 2022 | RHP | |
| Nicholas DiMarzo | NY | Eastchester | 2024 | 1B | |
| Trevor Dutra | NY | Iona Prep | 2021 | 1B | St. John's |
| Anthony Engongoro | NY | Iona Prep | 2023 | 3B | |
| Alex Esteverena | NY | Pelham Memorial | 2023 | LHP | |
| Andrew Fadda | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | 3B | |
| Anthony Falciglia | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2021 | 1B | CC Baltimore County-Essex |
| Joseph Fama | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | OF | |
| Peter Fama | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | SS | |
| Peter Fasciglione | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | SS | Notre Dame |
| Jason Fernandez | NY | N/A | 2024 | C | |
| Vito Gallello | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | 3B | Gettysburg College |
| Jason Garcia | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | RHP | |
| Jaihden Garrett | NY | All Hallows | 2020 | RHP | |
| Parker Gibbons | NY | Harrison | 2021 | OF | Kenyon College |
| Thomas Gleason | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | RHP | |
| Kyle Gordon | CT | Norwalk | 2020 | OF | Central Connecticut State |
| Luke Green | NY | Pelham Memorial | 2023 | C | |
| Jack Griffiths | NY | Rye | 2021 | OF | |
| Garrett Hah | NY | Horace Mann | 2021 | OF | |
| Matt Halas | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2020 | SS | |
| Joseph Healy | NY | Regis | 2021 | 2B | |
| Ted Heraty | NY | Bronxville | 2023 | RHP | |
| Sean Holley | NY | Pelham Memorial | 2020 | LHP | |
| Chris Hudson | NY | Port Chester | 2020 | LHP | |
| Ryan Hunter | NY | Eastchester | 2021 | SS | |
| J.Zachary Indellicate | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | RHP | |
| Danneuris Infante | CT | The Gunnery | 2021 | 2B | Cloud County CC |
| Ethan Jaquette | NY | Bronxville | 2023 | SS | |
| Owen Jaquette | NY | Bronxville | 2020 | RHP | Drew University |
| Kenneth Jorge | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | OF | |
| Matthew Kahn | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2020 | RHP | Siena |
| Jimmy Keenan | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | C | St. John's |
| Braden Kunda | NY | Eastchester | 2020 | SS | |
| Justin Lee | NY | Tuckahoe | 2020 | SS | |
| Zachary Levinson | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | RHP | |
| Jacob Liberati | NY | Tuckahoe | 2024 | C | |
| Greg Lucien | NY | Harrison | 2020 | 2B | |
| Joey Mancuso | NY | Eastchester | 2021 | C | |
| Jack Marino | NY | Fordham Prep | 2021 | 2B | |
| Jack Mathews | CT | Brunswick | 2020 | SS | Trinity College (CT) |
| Fabrizio Mattia | NY | New Rochelle | 2022 | SS | |
| Jack McBride | NY | Fordham Prep | 2021 | 3B | |
| Mark McNenney | NY | Pelham Memorial | 2020 | 1B | |
| Javier Mendez | NY | Pelham | 2021 | OF | |
| Michael Meyers | NY | Tuckahoe | 2022 | RHP | Shenandoah University |
| Anthony Mezzaucella | NY | New Rochelle | 2023 | OF | |
| Nick Mirando | NY | Mamaroneck | 2022 | RHP | Manhattanville College |
| Robert Mirrione | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | SS | Scranton |
| Frank Mondrone | NY | Iona Prep | 2021 | RHP | |
| Matthew Mondrone | NY | Tuckahoe | 2020 | LHP | |
| Raymond Murphy | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2021 | C | |
| Luke Nascimento | NY | Iona Prep | 2023 | C | Bucknell |
| Ryan Nascimento | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | C | |
| Peter Ortiz | NY | Regis | 2021 | C | |
| Ryan Osso | NY | Eastchester | 2021 | RHP | |
| Jaime C. Padilla | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2022 | C | Shenandoah University |
| TJ Palma | NY | Iona Prep | 2020 | SS | |
| Ian Panker | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | C | |
| Alvin Paulino | NY | St. Raymond HS for Boys | 2021 | C | |
| Dominic Pesca | NY | Cardinal Spellman | 2020 | RHP | |
| Justin Pesco | NY | Iona Prep | 2021 | RHP | |
| Timothy Pettus | NY | Pelham | 2022 | 1B | |
| Tyler Pfeiffer | NY | Eastchester | 2022 | OF | |
| Thomas Plunkett | NY | Mamaroneck | 2020 | RHP | Scranton |
| Anthony Pressimone | NY | Stepinac | 2020 | C | |
| Thomas Provenzano | NY | New Rochelle | 2021 | SS | Gettysburg College |
| Ralphie Pulitano | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2022 | 3B | |
| Frank Raneri | NY | Fordham Prep | 2021 | OF | |
| Nicholas Raneri | NY | Bronxville | 2024 | 2B | |
| Jonathan Reich | NY | Mamaroneck | 2020 | 2B | |
| Michael Rideout | NY | Tuckahoe | 2024 | 2B | |
| Aiden Riebe | NY | New Rochelle | 2021 | 3B | |
| Tyler Rosenberg | NY | Horace Greeley | 2020 | LHP | |
| John Russell | NY | Eastchester | 2022 | C | Hartford |
| Ramon Salazar | NY | Ramon Salazar | 2020 | 3B | |
| Anthony Saputo | NY | Stepinac | 2020 | 2B | |
| Merritt Scott | NY | Iona Prep | 2021 | OF | |
| Thomas Shelton | NY | Pelham Memorial | 2022 | 3B | |
| Matthew Soto | NY | Archbishop Stepinac | 2020 | 1B | |
| Aidan Sullivan | CT | Canterbury | 2022 | OF | Swarthmore College |
| Michael Sullivan | NY | Harrison | 2021 | 3B | |
| Mark Surhoff | NY | Rye | 2020 | C | |
| Charlie Tanico | NY | Harrison | 2020 | C | |
| Michael Taylor | NY | Eastchester | 2020 | LHP | SUNY-Cortland |
| Jaden Torrado | NY | Iona Preparatory | 2020 | OF | |
| Charlie Vail | NY | Bronxville | 2021 | RHP | |
| Charles Vega | NY | Iona Prep | 2021 | RHP | |
| Devin Walpole | NY | Fordham Prep | 2020 | OF |