Underclass Games
| Name | State | School | Class | Pos | Commitment |
| Hudson Allen | IN | Southridge | 2024 | MIF | |
| Brock Allison | IN | Brownsburg | 2023 | 3B | |
| Lane Allison | IN | Perry Meridian | 2023 | OF | Grace College |
| AJ Beggs | IN | Center Grove | 2024 | C | Southwestern Illinois JC |
| Jack Beyl | IN | Providence | 2024 | OF | Embry-Riddle Aeronautical University |
| Caleb Bowling | IN | Plymouth | 2024 | 3B | |
| Joel Bueltel | IN | Forest Park | 2024 | OF | |
| Kevin Corcoran | IN | Illiana Chrstian | 2023 | OF | Webster University |
| John Curl | IN | Kokomo | 2023 | 1B | Indiana State |
| Cole Decker | IN | North | 2024 | OF | Indiana |
| Reece Dew | IN | Zionsville Community | 2024 | SS | |
| Amere Dingle | IN | Westfield High School | 2024 | OF | |
| Brayden Erickson | IN | Pioneer | 2024 | RHP | |
| Sam Everts | IN | Westfield | 2024 | RHP | Capital University |
| Kameron Gethers | IN | Lake Central | 2023 | OF | |
| Tyson Good | IN | Lewis Cass | 2023 | RHP | |
| Jackson Gwin | IN | William Henry Harrison High School | 2024 | Concordia University (NE) | |
| Kevin Hall Jr | IN | Munster | 2023 | UTILITY | Grambling State |
| Mark Hamby | IN | University | 2024 | C | |
| Hanson Hinshaw | IN | Zionsville | 2023 | C | |
| Cody Jackson | IN | Our Lady of Providence | 2023 | 3B | Anderson University (IN) |
| Nathan Julius | IN | Our Lady of Providence | 2023 | OF | |
| Grady Kepplin | IN | New Prairie | 2023 | OF | |
| Brandon Lynch | IN | Penn | 2024 | 1B | |
| Zach McLean | IN | Columbus North | 2024 | 1B | |
| Matty Mortrud | IN | Westview | 2023 | 1B | |
| Seth Nanna | IN | Westfield | 2023 | LHP | Lewis University |
| Jacob Oliver | IN | Marian | 2024 | 2B | |
| JJ Oliver | IN | Mishawaka Marian | 2024 | SS | |
| Colton Pribyl | IN | Kankakee Valley | 2023 | SS | |
| Ryan Rayburn | IN | Columbus North | 2024 | LHP | Vincennes JC |
| Chase Redmon | IN | New Palestine | 2024 | OF | |
| Luka Romic | IN | Lake Central | 2023 | 3B | South Suburban JC |
| Conner Roth | IN | Northridge | 2024 | C | |
| Pryce Rucker | IN | Franklin Community | 2023 | 1B | |
| Kade Sainz | IN | Northridge | 2023 | SS | |
| Bryson Scales | IN | Jeffersonville | 2023 | OF | |
| Nathan Schoenherr | IN | Concord | 2023 | OF | |
| Corbin Snyder | IN | Eastern | 2024 | RHP | Butler |
| Zachary Stawski | IN | St Joseph South Bend | 2023 | OF | Anderson University (IN) |
| Tyler Stewart | IN | Highland | 2023 | SS | South Suburban JC |
| Dylan Toler | IN | Borden | 2023 | OF | Kentucky Wesleyan College |
| Chad Washburn | IN | Kokomo | 2024 | OF | |
| Bryce Yoder | IN | Homestead | 2023 | C | Marietta College |