Micah Toler, Heritage Hills High School (IN), 2027 Positional Profile: OF/SS Body: 6-2, 185-pounds. Lean, wiry frame with visible athleticism and twitch throughout. Hit: RHH Tall, narrow setup with hands high and tight to start. Comfortable timing in the box with a shorter leg lift stride. Shoulders get coiled at land with strong rotational ability on axis. Shows some bat and hand speed with some real bat to ball abilities. Power: 96 max exit velocity, averaged 83.7 mph. 363' max distance. Arm: RH. OF-80 mph. Confident mover with soft hands and an easy ball to hand transfer. Loose arm action from an OTT slot. ATH: 6.67 runner in the 60. 1.64 and 3.72 in the 10 and 30 yard splits. Vizual Edge: 78.7 Edge Score
5/12/26
+ OF Micah Toler, Heritage Hills: An athletic, projectable 6-foot-3, 185-pounder, Toler really stands out visually with his frame. I saw him in four at-bats during my look where he went 1-for-4 with a single and a couple fly balls. Offensively, he features an athletic right-handed swing with some present rawness in the operation, leaving room for continued polish. He posted a 6.65 60-yard dash at a fall scout day and the arm strength plays above-average from the outfield as well. While the impact in my look was modest, the production this spring has been loud; through 10 games, Toler is hitting .510 with 10 doubles, 2 triples, and 3 home runs. The frame and athletic actions really standout for the three-sport athlete. Toler is an uncommitted junior we’ll continue to monitor closely moving forward.
10/05/25
The biggest winner amongst recruitable talent, Toler began the day with a bang - turning in a 6.65 60-time. The athleticism and twitch is really beginning to blossom, allowing for CF projections, and his projectable, high-waisted, 6-foot-2, 180-pound frame still has plenty of room to grow. He took a solid round of batting practice, showing off a direct bat path that he used to leverage balls with authority to the pullside for big impacts when synced. There is a tendency to over-rotate that still needs cleaned up, but the projections, paired with 96-plus exits on the top-end, a 6.65 60, and an above average outfield arm (85 mph) - makes Toler a T10 uncommitted outfielder in the state's 27 group
9/25/24
+ '27 OF Micah Toler (Heritage Hills) is a projectable, athletic outfielder that showed well throughout the day. Holding a high-waisted, 6-foot-1, 165 pound frame, Toler burned an event-best 6.89 60-yard dash before putting together several backspun liners in his batting practice round. Toler showed a controlled, athletic move to the baseball with a tight, connected bat path, with his best ball jumping off the bat at 89 mph. It is an easy operation in the batter's box and he will grow into power as he adds strength to his long-levered frame. In the outfield, Toler moves around with an athletic gait and showed soft hands with fringy arm strength. After seeing varsity time as a freshman last year, Toler is a breakout candidate in southern Indiana with several traits to dream on.
6/11/24
Micah Toler, Heritage Hills High School (IN), 2027 Positional Profile: OF/3B Body: 6-0, 165-pounds. Lean, athleitc build. Strong projectability. Hit: RHH. Balanced start with tall back elbow. Slow controlled load into backside. Tends to land heavy on front side. hands work tight to body in path, present ability to lift, some strength. Interesting follow Torque in lower half leads to abv/avg bat speed. 70.4 mph bat speed with 5 G's of rotational acceleration. Power: 91 max exit velocity, averaged 81.0 mph. 312' max distance. Arm: RH. OF-80 mph. Longerm loose arm action from an over the top slot. Arm displays some whippy traits. Defense: Fundamental footwork in the outfield with soft hands. Strong ball to hand skills with developed throwing mechanics. ATH: 7.15 runner in the 60.
Draft Reports
Contact
Premium Content Area
To unlock contact information, you need to purchase a ScoutPLUS subscription.
Positional Profile: OF/SS
Body: 6-2, 185-pounds. Lean, wiry frame with visible athleticism and twitch throughout.
Hit: RHH Tall, narrow setup with hands high and tight to start. Comfortable timing in the box with a shorter leg lift stride. Shoulders get coiled at land with strong rotational ability on axis. Shows some bat and hand speed with some real bat to ball abilities.
Power: 96 max exit velocity, averaged 83.7 mph. 363' max distance.
Arm: RH. OF-80 mph. Confident mover with soft hands and an easy ball to hand transfer. Loose arm action from an OTT slot.
ATH: 6.67 runner in the 60. 1.64 and 3.72 in the 10 and 30 yard splits.
Vizual Edge: 78.7 Edge Score
The biggest winner amongst recruitable talent, Toler began the day with a bang - turning in a 6.65 60-time. The athleticism and twitch is really beginning to blossom, allowing for CF projections, and his projectable, high-waisted, 6-foot-2, 180-pound frame still has plenty of room to grow. He took a solid round of batting practice, showing off a direct bat path that he used to leverage balls with authority to the pullside for big impacts when synced. There is a tendency to over-rotate that still needs cleaned up, but the projections, paired with 96-plus exits on the top-end, a 6.65 60, and an above average outfield arm (85 mph) - makes Toler a T10 uncommitted outfielder in the state's 27 group
+ '27 OF Micah Toler (Heritage Hills) is a projectable, athletic outfielder that showed well throughout the day. Holding a high-waisted, 6-foot-1, 165 pound frame, Toler burned an event-best 6.89 60-yard dash before putting together several backspun liners in his batting practice round. Toler showed a controlled, athletic move to the baseball with a tight, connected bat path, with his best ball jumping off the bat at 89 mph. It is an easy operation in the batter's box and he will grow into power as he adds strength to his long-levered frame. In the outfield, Toler moves around with an athletic gait and showed soft hands with fringy arm strength. After seeing varsity time as a freshman last year, Toler is a breakout candidate in southern Indiana with several traits to dream on.
Micah Toler, Heritage Hills High School (IN), 2027
Positional Profile: OF/3B
Body: 6-0, 165-pounds. Lean, athleitc build. Strong projectability.
Hit: RHH. Balanced start with tall back elbow. Slow controlled load into backside. Tends to land heavy on front side. hands work tight to body in path, present ability to lift, some strength. Interesting follow Torque in lower half leads to abv/avg bat speed. 70.4 mph bat speed with 5 G's of rotational acceleration.
Power: 91 max exit velocity, averaged 81.0 mph. 312' max distance.
Arm: RH. OF-80 mph. Longerm loose arm action from an over the top slot. Arm displays some whippy traits.
Defense: Fundamental footwork in the outfield with soft hands. Strong ball to hand skills with developed throwing mechanics.
ATH: 7.15 runner in the 60.