Prep Baseball Report

NY 2025 Rankings Update

Joe Walentin
Scouting Director, NY

The summer has concluded and school has officially started, which means it's time for our staff to sit down for a modest pre-fall update to the 2025 class rankings. A couple of power arms lead the way out of NYC, 3B/RHP Justice de Jong (Poly Prep) and RHP Miguel Sime (Poly Prep).

A handful of new faces jumped into the Top-10, including a pair of uncommitted names-to-know as SS Mateo Noto (Beacon School) comes in at #5 after an impressive Future Games appearance and C Owen Ten Oever (Poly Prep), a top hitting backstop jumped in at #6. 

Included below is a look at the Top 10 in the class, a full list of the 225 ranked players and the top uncommitted by position


top 10


Justice de Jong 3B / RHP / Poly Prep, NY / 2025









Miguel Sime RHP / OF / Poly Prep, NY / 2025








Jordan Serrano OF / The Stony Brook School, NY / 2025









Drew Kindlon RHP / OF / Albany Academy, NY / 2025









Mateo Noto SS / 2B / Beacon School, NY / 2025









Owen ten Oever C / 1B / Poly Prep, NY / 2025









Mason Holloway RHP / 2B / Horseheads, NY / 2025


Plenty of projection left in the 6-foot-1, 160 lb frame. Commands a quality 3-pitch mix featuring a fastball that sits upper 80's.





Hudson Cavallo RHP / OF / Arlington, NY / 2025









Anthony Frobose SS / RHP / Lakeland, NY / 2025









Ryan Strnad C / 3B / Kennedy Catholic Prep, NY / 2025










Two Way: Todd Feurtado III | Joey Tagliavia

 RHP: Scott Hanson | Tyler Johnston 

LHP: Steven Bronson | Micah Hays

C:  Branston Lindquist | Steven Santos

CINF:  Aaron Lugo | Ryan Pettograsso

MINF: Miguel Matos | James Haughton

OF: Jack Roventini | Luke Becker