| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. |
| Ryan Bothwell | ON | Napanee District Secondary School | 2015 | 3B |
| Evan Brock | NY | Rush-Henrietta | 2023 | 3B |
| Lucas Brown | ON | Humberside Collegiate | 2022 | SS |
| Trey Brown | NY | Aquinas Institute | 2018 | 2B |
| Breton Button-Sibley | base | Glace Bay | 2020 | 1B |
| Jonathan Catapano | NY | McQuaid Jesuit | 2016 | OF |
| Luke Connors | ON | Heart Lake | 2023 | C |
| Andrew Czubaj | NY | John F. Kennedy High School | 2016 | C |
| Maximo Fernandez | NY | A. Philip Randolph | 2017 | RHP |
| Philip Ferranti, III | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2017 | C |
| Paul Fiene | NY | Sachem North | 2023 | OF |
| Nathan Hampson | NY | Victor | 2018 | LHP |
| Ryan Hill | NY | Webster Thomas | 2018 | 2B |
| Matt Johnson | NY | Fairport | 2016 | RHP |
| Connor Kiefer | NY | City Honors | 2021 | SS |
| Evan Lang | ON | Burlington Central | 2017 | LHP |
| Sam Loew | NY | Binghamton | 2017 | SS |
| Evan Magill | ON | Notre Dame | 2018 | C |
| Ryan Marketell | NY | Webster Thomas | 2016 | RHP |
| Logan Martella-Tasick | NY | Penfield | 2017 | OF |
| Stuart Martin | ON | John F Ross C.V.I | 2016 | RHP |
| Anthony May | NY | CW Baker | 2017 | 2B |
| Julien Mendoza | NY | Fairport | 2022 | SS |
| Mike Perlo | NY | Fairport | 2016 | C |
| CJ Phelps | NY | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | C |
| Ethan Pollard | ON | Heart Lake | 2020 | LHP |
| William Russotti | NY | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | OF |
| Max Schmarder | NY | Olmsted | 2020 | C |
| Nick Schuster | OH | Elyria | 2022 | LHP |
| Michael Sculli | NY | Canandaigua | 2019 | LHP |
| Patrick Sherron | NY | Rush-Henrietta | 2020 | RHP |
| Bryan Speranza | NY | Aquinas | 2016 | |
| Tyler Stack | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2022 | LHP |
| Matthew Wagner | ON | Bishop Smith Catholic | 2015 | SS |
| Jadon Wanat | NY | Williamsville North | 2024 | OF |
| Lucas West | NY | Auburn | 2023 | LHP |
