| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. |
| Sean Becker | PA | Lansdale Catholic | 2014 | C |
| David Bernard Jr | NY | Schenectady | 2022 | 1B |
| Tommy Bressmer | NY | Long Island Lutheran | 2023 | OF |
| Nathan Carrillo | AZ | Horizon | 2024 | C |
| Aditya Chandel | NJ | St. Joseph | 2017 | RHP |
| Caleb Constance | MA | Bridgton Academy | 2022 | C |
| Christian Corey | NY | Locust Valley | 2023 | RHP |
| Thomas Digiorgi | NY | Half Hollow Hills West | 2014 | |
| Austin Feigin | NJ | Toms River North | 2017 | SS |
| Jonathan Fenwick | AZ | N/A | 2020 | OF |
| Ulisses Ferraz | NJ | St. Peter's Prep | 2022 | SS |
| Jace Gilligan | NJ | Passaic County Tech | 2023 | C |
| Jonny Gilligan | NJ | PCTI | 2023 | SS |
| Parker Gray | TX | Marshall | 2020 | 2B |
| Landon Harwell | MO | St. John Vianney | 2023 | |
| Landon Harwell | MO | St. John Vianney | 2023 | SS |
| Jarred Jackette | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | OF |
| Hunter Lefkus | NJ | Donovan Catholic | 2024 | RHP |
| Kyle Mahady | PA | Nazareth Area | 2020 | RHP |
| Robert Nunez | NY | Monsignor McClancy Memorial | 2021 | LHP |
| Julio Ortiz | NJ | Harrison HS | 2018 | OF |
| Cristian Perez | CT | Cheshire Academy | 2020 | 1B |
| Michael Pollard | OH | Walsh Jesuit | 2021 | OF |
| Linden Reaburn | AZ | Casteel | 2023 | RHP |
| Wilfred Santiago | MA | Archbishop William | 2024 | C |
| Alec Schmitz | WI | Sun Prairie | 2020 | RHP |
| Nicholas Sciubba | NY | Cardinal Spellman | 2016 | SS |
| Tyler Smith | NY | Stony Brook | 2021 | C |
| Brighton Taylor | FL | Timber Creek | 2020 | RHP |
| Michael Tiseo | NY | St. Francis Prep | 2022 | 3B |
| Andrew Veit | NY | Bellport | 2019 | SS |
| Jake Wagner | NJ | Pope John XXIII | 2020 | SS |
| Cole Watson | ON | St. Thomas Aquinas | 2020 | C |
| Cole Watson | ON | St. Thomas Aquinas | 2021 | C |
| James White | GA | Decatur | 2021 | 1B |
| Kedric Zimmer | GA | Jackson County | 2021 | RHP |
