| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. |
| Jason Agresti | NY | John F. Kennedy | 2014 | |
| Caden Albright | NY | Cortland | 2025 | SS |
| Ben Anderson | NY | Shenendehowa | 2016 | C |
| Thomas Babalis | NJ | Somerville | 2018 | LHP |
| Rob Brown | PA | Penncrest | 2015 | LHP |
| Dominic Buonadonna | NJ | Millville | 2019 | RHP |
| Jack Collins | NY | Canisius | 2018 | RHP |
| Jake Conroy | NY | Windsor | 2015 | RHP |
| Isaiah Corry | NY | Clarence | 2019 | SS |
| Cooper Crunick | NY | Canandaigua | 2019 | 3B |
| Jake Dally | PA | Nazareth | 2023 | 2B |
| Jaden DeLawder | NY | FDR | 2021 | C |
| Tim Denet | NY | Iona Prep | 2024 | 3B |
| Dominick DiRado | NY | Vestal | 2018 | LHP |
| Justin Drpich | NY | John Jay | 2016 | 2B |
| Luke Dziados | NY | Cicero North Syracuse | 2017 | RHP |
| Jake Evans | NY | Liverpool | 2017 | SS |
| Daniel Franchi | NY | Center Moriches | 2015 | OF |
| Sam Freedman | PA | Penncrest | 2017 | C |
| Chase Fulford | PA | Central Bucks East | 2025 | SS |
| Dylan Gearhart | PA | Mount Union Area | 2019 | RHP |
| Douglas Goodwin | NY | Smithtown East | 2019 | RHP |
| Matt Gordon | PA | Grove City | 2014 | RHP |
| Conner Griffin | PA | Abington Heights | 2023 | RHP |
| Ben Griffith | MA | Shrewsbury | 2023 | RHP |
| Kevin Gsell | NJ | Seneca | 2018 | 3B |
| Logan Haskell | NY | Susquehanna Valley | 2021 | SS |
| Darian Herncane | PA | State College | 2013 | OF |
| Mason Holloway | NY | Horseheads | 2025 | RHP |
| Ian Kaiser | NJ | Montville | 2023 | LHP |
| Steven Kraus | NY | Hilton | 2024 | 1B |
| Ryan Lambert | NY | Colonie | 2017 | RHP |
| Brady Lesiak | NJ | Southern Regional | 2024 | RHP |
| Shane Marshall | NY | Webster Schroeder | 2017 | 3B |
| Colin Mason | NJ | Hunterdon Central | 2018 | OF |
| Daniel McAliney | NY | McQuaid Jesuit | 2022 | RHP |
| Chris McGee | NY | Jamesville-Dewitt | 2014 | |
| Anthony Meduri | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2015 | OF |
| Jackson Mitchell | NY | Warwick | 2023 | RHP |
| Brandon Ortiz | NY | Warwick | 2020 | SS |
| Christian Perez | NY | The Harvey School | 2020 | OF |
| Alex Persichetti | NJ | Gloucester Catholic | 2017 | SS |
| Eddie Posavec | PA | North Penn | 2013 | C |
| Tommy Reifler | NY | Garden City | 2019 | SS |
| Kevin Reilly | PA | Plymouth Whitemarsh | 2020 | C |
| Cameron Ringo | NY | Hamburg | 2015 | RHP |
| Justin Rosner | NY | Farmingdale | 2020 | RHP |
| Caden Rothbaum | FL | American Heritage Delray | 2021 | LHP |
| John Ryder | NY | Marlboro | 2024 | RHP |
| Trey Sajeski | PA | Council Rock South | 2023 | RHP |
| Greg Satriale | NY | Eastchester | 2016 | RHP |
| Michael Stellrecht | NY | Williamsville East | 2022 | SS |
| Evin Sullivan | PA | North Penn | 2021 | C |
| Andrew Tan | NJ | North Brunswick | 2019 | SS |
| Hayden Tarsia | NY | John Jay - East Fishkill | 2023 | RHP |
| Matt Tsukroff | NJ | Montville | 2015 | 1B |
| Cavan Tully | PA | Council Rock North | 2018 | 2B |
| Brady Walker | PA | North Star | 2016 | LHP |
| Tyler (TJ) Wegmann | NY | Vestal | 2016 | C |
| Jeremy Westaway | NJ | Morristown-Beard | 2015 | RHP |
| Jacob Wloczewski | PA | Whitehall | 2013 | RHP |
