| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. |
| Christian Aich | NJ | Sayreville War Memorial | 2019 | 1B |
| Daniel Allard | CT | East Lyme | 2020 | RHP |
| Anthony Apollaro | TX | Shelton School | 2021 | RHP |
| Nelson Arroyo | NY | John S. Burke Catholic | 2018 | RHP |
| Mason Baronian | NJ | Pascack Valley | 2021 | SS |
| Matthew Bass | NY | Tottenville | 2017 | OF |
| Grant Biederman | NY | Walt Whitman | 2021 | RHP |
| Brian Bohlander | NY | North Rockland | 2016 | 1B |
| John Carollo | NY | St. Peter's Boys High School | 2023 | C |
| Vincent Civitella | NJ | Clifton | 2021 | LHP |
| Sean Costello | NY | Seaford | 2023 | RHP |
| Justin Crispino | NY | Commack | 2022 | OF |
| Ryan Dacey | NJ | Mahwah | 2021 | OF |
| Ryan Degnan | NY | Carey | 2022 | RHP |
| Brian Espinal | NY | Cardinal Spellman | 2023 | RHP |
| Rafael Figuereo | NY | Stepinac | 2019 | SS |
| Andrew Fitzgerald | CT | Daniel Hand | 2016 | |
| Robbie Gilchrist | NY | North Salem | 2022 | RHP |
| Johnny Guarantano | NC | RJ Reynolds | 2018 | SS |
| Kameron Hartenstein | CT | Maloney | 2021 | C |
| Dominick Herald | NY | Christian Brothers Academy | 2016 | C |
| Nicholas Huchro | NY | Arlington | 2023 | RHP |
| Dylan Koch | NY | Yorktown | 2023 | 3B |
| Ethan Lynch | MA | Dover Sherborn | 2022 | RHP |
| Brendan McCann | NY | Kellenberg Memorial | 2022 | LHP |
| Nick Montagna | NY | Carmel | 2021 | SS |
| CJ Orrego | NJ | Wayne Hills | 2023 | C |
| Nicholas Palumbo | NJ | Wayne Hills | 2018 | RHP |
| Cristian Rodriguez | NY | Iona Prep | 2022 | OF |
| Tyler Rodriguez | NY | Cornwall | 2022 | LHP |
| Michael Roll | NJ | Bergen Catholic | 2018 | RHP |
| Justin Scotto | NJ | Monmouth Regional | 2018 | OF |
| Marco Siracusa | NJ | Bergen Catholic | 2019 | LHP |
| Chase Swain | NY | Trinity Pawling | 2021 | LHP |
| Benjamin Tullo | NY | Roy C. Ketcham | 2022 | 2B |
| Vincent Vartolone | NJ | Lodi | 2020 | RHP |
