| Name | State | School | Class | Pos. |
| Armando Albert | FL | Belen Jesuit Prep | 2019 | SS |
| Andy Axelson | NJ | Roxbury | 2018 | C |
| Jared Bellissimo | NJ | Toms River North | 2018 | LHP |
| Ethan Bowen | NJ | Shawnee | 2022 | RHP |
| Chris Brito | NJ | Perth Amboy | 2018 | 3B |
| Serafino Brito | NJ | Indian Hills | 2015 | RHP |
| Yomar Carreras | NJ | North Brunswick | 2024 | SS |
| Matthew Ciccone | NJ | Newark Academy | 2019 | RHP |
| Trevor Cohen | NJ | Holy Spirit | 2022 | OF |
| Anthony Condito | NJ | Nutley | 2016 | OF |
| Drew Conover | NJ | Voorhees | 2020 | RHP |
| Christian Coppola | NJ | Cedar Creek | 2022 | RHP |
| Kenny Cruz | NY | SOTA | 2016 | OF |
| Anthony DeRosa | NJ | Red Bank Catholic | 2017 | 3B |
| Tim Dezzi | NJ | Clearview Regional | 2017 | SS |
| Ty Doucette | base | TNXL Academy | 2023 | 1B |
| Luke Fithian | NJ | Ocean City | 2024 | RHP |
| Ryan Fleming | PA | Council Rock South | 2013 | OF |
| Garrett French | NJ | Middletown North | 2018 | RHP |
| Joe Gale | PA | Archbishop Wood | 2023 | OF |
| Thomas Genuario | NJ | St. Mary's | 2015 | OF |
| Kyle Gerace | NJ | Mainland Regional | 2016 | RHP |
| Mickey Gilligan | NJ | Lakeland Regional | 2026 | C |
| Andrew Goldan | NJ | St. Joe's Metuchen | 2022 | RHP |
| John Goodes | NJ | Rumson Fair-Haven | 2023 | RHP |
| Cole Hansen | NJ | Montgomery | 2021 | RHP |
| Jawuan Harris | FL | St. Thomas Aquinas | 2015 | OF |
| Adam Holland | PA | William Penn Charter | 2017 | OF |
| Jayson Hoopes | NJ | St. Augustine Prep | 2019 | RHP |
| Reece Horneck | NJ | Colts Neck | 2019 | 1B |
| Hunter Hoxie | CT | Jonathan Law | 2024 | LHP |
| Miles Kelly | NY | Shoreham Wading River | 2017 | 1B |
| Danny Kerr | NJ | Bishop Eustace | 2021 | RHP |
| Jack Kirchner | NJ | Bishop Eustace | 2023 | RHP |
| Zachary Konstantinovsky | NJ | North Brunswick | 2023 | RHP |
| JT Kroner | NJ | Colonia | 2022 | LHP |
| Joshua Kuroda-Gauer | NJ | Franklin | 2021 | SS |
| Ryan Lasko | NJ | Jackson Memorial | 2020 | OF |
| Landon Mack | NJ | Bishop Eustace Prep | 2024 | SS |
| Maximus Martin | NJ | Moorestown | 2022 | SS |
| Mike Martinez | NJ | Bergen Catholic | 2015 | OF |
| Xavier Massey | NJ | Audubon | 2022 | OF |
| Nick Matera | NJ | Morris Catholic | 2015 | C |
| Joe Mazza | NJ | Manalapan | 2021 | LHP |
| Evan McCoach | PA | Neumann Goretti | 2024 | OF |
| Aaron McLaughlin | NJ | Barnegat | 2017 | SS |
| Alejandro Morales | FL | Belen Jesuit | 2020 | LHP |
| Kyle Muller | NJ | Steinert | 2016 | RHP |
| Tevin Murray | PA | North Schuylkill | 2016 | LHP |
| Jackson Natili | PA | Peters Township | 2023 | C |
| Joe Neglia | NJ | St. Joseph Regional | 2016 | RHP |
| Jacob Newman | IL | Glenbrook South | 2018 | RHP |
| Mike Nyisztor | NJ | Toms River North | 2017 | SS |
| Bruce Parker | NJ | Haddonfield Memorial High School | 2024 | SS |
| Wyatt Parliament | NY | LaFargeville | 2022 | RHP |
| Devon Patel | TX | Klein Oak | 2019 | RHP |
| Nick Perez | NJ | The Hun School | 2015 | SS |
| Hugh Pinkney | ON | Silverthorn CI | 2022 | C |
| Isaiah Pinkney | NJ | Audubon | 2022 | 1B |
| Sam Portnoy | NJ | Eastern | 2020 | RHP |
| Kyle Potthoff | MO | Marquette | 2019 | RHP |
| Eric Reardon | NJ | North Brunswick | 2016 | 1B |
| Joshua Rodriguez | NJ | St. Joseph's Montvale | 2019 | OF |
| Danny Rogers | NY | Troy | 2021 | SS |
| Kevin Romero | NJ | Don Bosco | 2015 | RHP |
| Julius Rosado | NJ | South River | 2025 | SS |
| Matt Rowe | NJ | Metuchen | 2021 | RHP |
| Anthony Russo | PA | Archbishop Wood | 2016 | RHP |
| Harry Rutkowski | NJ | Woodbridge | 2017 | RHP |
| Tony SantaMaria | NJ | ACIT | 2020 | SS |
| Pablo Santos | NJ | Don Bosco Prep | 2022 | SS |
| Dante Scafidi | NJ | Gloucester Catholic | 2015 | LHP |
| Richie Schiekofer | NJ | Millburn | 2017 | OF |
| Davis Schneider | NJ | Eastern Regional | 2017 | 3B |
| Parker Scott | NJ | Ridgewood | 2018 | RHP |
| Justin Shadek | NJ | Seton Hall Prep | 2023 | RHP |
| Garrett Shapiro | NJ | Millville | 2026 | RHP |
| Jason Shockley | MD | Sussex Tech | 2021 | C |
| Grant Shulman | NJ | Wall | 2019 | RHP |
| Evan Sleight | MA | Belmont Hill | 2019 | OF |
| David Soto | NY | Brentwood | 2018 | SS |
| Jack Sweeney | NJ | Allentown | 2024 | OF |
| Jordan Sweeney | NJ | Egg Harbor Township | 2019 | 1B |
| Justin Sweeney | NJ | Egg Harbor Township | 2023 | RHP |
| Andrew Tofolo | NJ | Eastern | 2021 | RHP |
| Nick Tomasetto | NJ | West Deptford | 2023 | SS |
| Kevin Welsh | NJ | No. Burlington | 2016 | SS |
| Tyler Wiltsey | NJ | Audubon | 2025 | OF |
| Donovan Zsak | NJ | St. Joseph's Metuchen | 2022 | LHP |
